• Skip to header navigation
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • E-mail
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Faith in Older People

Enabling a better understanding of the importance of the spiritual dimension to the well-being of older people

  • Home
  • Why Spiritual Care?
  • About FiOP
    • History
    • Staff and Trustees
    • Partners
    • Governance/Annual Report & Accounts
    • Newsletters
  • Current Projects
    • Dementia care and faith communities
    • Spiritual care education
    • Other work
  • Listening and Caring in Confidence
  • Resources
  • Contact

Spiritual care in general practice: what’s happening in practice and training?

Posted on 17th February 2020

Although a commitment to spiritual care exists in the curriculum of the Royal College of GPs for GP training and in the General Medical Council’s Good Medical Practice, describing what spiritual care is, and how GPs should be trained in it, is quite problematic. Some light has been shed on this recently by two thoughtful research articles by Aviemore GP Dr Alastair Appleby, with Prof John Swinton, Professor of Divinity at the University of Aberdeen and colleagues.

GPs themselves have a wide range of attitudes to spirituality, as you might expect. They surveyed 87 GPs in the North of Scotland, and found that were unclear what spirituality meant as a concept—perhaps they are not alone in this! However, ‘most but not all believed it to be important and to concern a potentially fundamental human and psychological need for meaning and purpose.’ They found that only 8% wished no involvement in spiritual care, 28% had reservations, 46% were willing to undertake this and 12% were keen. However, despite this (58% keen or willing to be involved in spiritual care), 36% reported that they tended not to discuss spiritual matters with their patients. Only 10% said that their training in spiritual care was adequate.

It is clear, therefore, that there is a gap between the willingness of GPs to discuss spiritual matters with patients and their practice in doing so. They feel inadequately trained to provide spiritual care and to deliver this training to colleagues. The authors suggest that the secular scientific basis of medical training may be at the heart of this, and that the current biomedical paradigm effectively discriminates against important approaches to health and wellness based on the humanities.

Their answers include an examination of what learning might help here, being honest about the current failings, admitting that there is a conceptual problem in medical education and practice which needs reform, and integrating training throughout the GP curriculum.

I believe that looking after the patient in a holistic person-centred way must include recognising and attending to spiritual dimensions, if that is what the patient wishes. This is not at all easy in an NHS in which there are great pressures on GP time and on GPs’ own internal resources. However, extension of Chaplaincy and other providers may help here. There is a current move in primary care towards social prescribing; spiritual care could be an interesting and valuable exemplar of this. As well as this, the answer may lie not just in reform of GP training, but in better support and more time for GPs to explore, through supported self-reflection, their own needs for spirituality and meaning in life. The Finnish philosopher Frank Martela has written extensively about meaning. Meaning in life, he suggests, is about making yourself meaningful to others in a way that gives your own life purpose. We should be grateful to Dr Appleby, Prof Swinton and their colleagues for having started the debate.

Professor John Gillies

Dr John Gillies is an Edinburgh graduate who has worked in Malawi and as a general practitioner in rural Scotland, latterly in Selkirk for 16 years. He has been an undergraduate tutor, a GP educational supervisor and a training programme director with NHS Education Scotland.

3 February 2020

Filed Under: Blog

Primary Sidebar

Archive

Footer

Current Projects

There is a growing awareness among both families and professionals that spiritual care is an essential component of holistic, person-centre care. FiOP has developed a range of projects to address today’s challenges:

  • Dementia care and faith communities
  • Spiritual care education
  • Other work

Upcoming Events

  1. Mental Health, Older People and Faith Communities

    16th March - 4:30 pm - 6:00 pm
  2. The Malcolm Goldsmith Lecture 2021

    11th May - 4:30 pm - 6:00 pm
  3. We Need to Talk About Death and Dying

    20th May - 10:00 am - 3:00 pm

View All Events

Latest news and blog

  • Faith Communities and Mental Health

    16th February 2021
    The mental wellbeing of our society is critically important if …Read articleon Faith Communities and Mental Health
  • Learning more deeply to recognise and serve the community, Part 1

    1st February 2021
    Last year, when we thought we had seen the peak …Read articleon Learning more deeply to recognise and serve the community, Part 1
  • ‘I’m not ageist!  I love the old dears…’

    18th January 2021
    The events of 2020 were “unprecedented”, extraordinary, challenging, and sadly, …Read articleon ‘I’m not ageist!  I love the old dears…’
Read all articles

Subscribe to our newsletter

  • Name
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility
  • Sitemap

© 2017 Faith in Older People is a registered company SC 322915. Limited by guarantee with charitable status. Registered Charity No. SC038225. Registered Address: 21a Grosvenor Crescent, Edinburgh EH12 5EL

Site design and build by graphics.coop · Powered by WordPress

OSCR logo